Columbia Board of Education

Regular Meeting

May 19, 2008

7:30 P.M.

Horace W. Porter School Library Media Center

 

Board Members Present:   Paula Belekewicz, Carol Coley-Vice Chairperson, Linda Green, Lisa Jurovaty, William Mulcahy, Nelson Petrone-Chairman

 

Board Members Absent:   Michael Neckermann

 

Administration Present:    Richard Saddlemire, Francine Coss, Jean Trask  

 

Staff Present:                 Cheryl Parrott, Marian Lowry, Heather Montanile, Madeline Skinner, Christian Urban,

                                    Lynn Mondazzi    

 

Citizens Present:              Connie Medeiros, Wendy Pallas, Mary Ellen Fritz, Amy Raffa, Amy Poverman, Kerry Hoffman, Laurie Rogers, Maria Gratton      

 

I.        Call to Order

      Chairman Nelson Petrone called the May 19, 2008 regular meeting to order at 7:32 p.m. 

        

II.      Approval of May 5, 2008 Regular Meeting Minutes - Take Action  

P. Belekewicz MOVED and W. Mulcahy SECONDED to approve the May 5, 2008 Regular Meeting Minutes as presented.

 

MOTION CARRIES: 6-0

 

III.    Approval of May 12, 2008 Special Meeting Minutes - Take Action

 

C. Coley MOVED and P. Belekewicz SECONDED to approve the May 12, 2008 Special Meeting Minutes as presented.

 

MOTION CARRIES: 5-0-1

P. Belekewicz, C. Coley, L. Jurovaty, W. Mulcahy, N. Petrone VOTED FOR THE MOTION

L. Green ABSTAINED

 

Change to the agenda:

C. Coley MOVED and L. Green SECONDED to add to the agenda Action Item IX.B. 2008/2009 Hot Lunch Price Increase Approval.

 

MOTION CARRIES: 6-0

           

IV.      Comments from the Audience (Bylaws of the Board #9300)

Time allotted for public participation–30 minutes, time allotted for an individual speaker–3 minutes

 

Conie Medieros asked if citizens will be allowed to speak at the May 20th Public Budget Hearing. (yes) It seems that the Board has not considered input or recommendations from Porter’s administrators in regards to the budget cuts.  (The Board considers Dr. Saddlemire as its liaison to the administration and considers that the administrators know what is best for Porter.)  Wendy Pallas asked if the $400,000 budget cuts will be listed so the public can see the impact of the cuts. (Dr. Saddlemire has contacted the attorney to see what is acceptable for publication.)  Connie Medeiros would like to remind Board members that they are representing all Columbia children not just their own.  Amy Raffa asked about next year’s third full-day kindergarten classroom configuration.  (Dr. Saddlemire explained the third kindergarten classroom will be located in close proximity to the kindergarten wing and next to a boys and girls lavatory.  The administration will assess the location after the 2008/09 school year.)                 

 

V.       Correspondence/Communications/Information

A.      Darien Parmenter, Porter Grade 7 Student Selected to Attend Lead America’s National Junior Leaders Conference                             on Business and Entrepreneurship- Mrs. Coley congratulated Darien Parmenter for being selected to

attend this conference in Washington, D.C.

 

 

V.       Correspondence/Communications/Information - continued

B.       Willimantic Chronicle Album:

- Saturday Special - Sarah Marshall, Grade 6 H.W. Porter Student

- Snow Princess - Samantha D’Auteuil, Grade 6 H.W.P. Student

- The Long Night - Noah Sternat, Grade 6 H.W.P. Student

- Quiet – Marissa Gardner, Grade 6 H.W. P. Student

Mrs. Belekewicz commended all the grade 6 students who were published in the Chronicle Album.

C.       May 1, 2008 Horace W. Porter School Enrollment

D.      May 1, 2008 Porter Principal’s Weekly Newsletter

E.       May 8, 2008 Porter Principal’s Weekly Newsletter

F.       May 15, 2008 Porter Principal’s Weekly Newsletter

G.      Revised 2007/2008 Horace W. Porter School Staff List

H.      Grant Funds to be Redirected in Columbia – 05/02/08 Willimantic Chronicle

I.        Lake Vote Seems Too Exclusive - 05/8/08 Willimantic Chronicle Opinion

J.        Secrets of Board Success - American School Board Journal/April 2008

K.       Bargaining: It’s in Your Best Interest - American School Board Journal/April 2008

L.       The Merit Scale - American School Board Journal/April 2008

M.      A Former Union Rep Was Elected to the Board? - American School Board Journal/April 2008

N.      Part-Time Superintendent - May 2008 District Administration

O.      Slashed Ed Budget Impacts Class Size – 05/14/08 Willimantic Chronicle

P.       Mrs. Kate Starkey to the Willimantic Chronicle Editor – 5/15/08

 

VI.         Presentations

A.   Porter Hot Lunch Update – Mr. Christian Urban, Porter Hot Lunch Director

 

Mr. Urban informed the Board the U.S. Department of Agriculture Food and Nutrition Survey Costs findings show combined labor, food and indirect costs necessary to provide a school lunch are greater than the Federal reimbursement, commodity entitlement and average price paid by students who do not qualify for a free school lunch.  Milk prices have increased 6% and general groceries are up 8 – 12%.  For each delivery a fuel surcharge is now added.  Mr. Urban shared 2007/2008 hot lunch prices for other CT towns.  Districts with high schools serving ala carte menu items earn higher revenues and average out the elementary schools that are losing money.  Mr. Urban recommends raising lunch prices for the 2008/09 school year by $.50 for students ($3.00) and staff ($3.50). 

 

Board members discussed the possibility of serving fewer lunches if the price is increased, reducing hot lunch personnel, the $10,000 in products Columbia receives from the state, the commodities that will be cut July through November by the state, and charging more for ala carte items rather than increasing lunch prices.  Board members will vote on this proposal this evening.       

 

B.      Language Arts Update – Mrs. Madeline Skinner, Language Arts Specialist

 

Mrs. Skinner told the Board she is proud to update members on Porter’s Language Arts program.  Mrs. Skinner began by reviewing the Language Arts Curriculum Standards and Programs (CT standards, CMT strands, grade level expectations, and supporting programs). 

 

The Houghton Mifflin Reading Program for grades K-4 was implemented in 2007/08.  This program was developed based upon scientific evidence of the National Reading Panel and is strongly aligned with CT framework standards.  This program is a comprehensive assessment which monitors student progress and builds student independence.  There is a strong early literacy phonetic component, emphasis on reading comprehension, consistent reading strategies and vocabulary, motivating and diverse reading literacy selections, fiction and non-fiction literacy selections, and a guided reading trade book approach. 

 

The Sitton Word Study Program for grades 1-8 was piloted this year.  This program highlights spelling in application, word study approach, priority words that must be used in all writing, and core words that are continually practiced and tested throughout the year for mastery. 

 

Mrs. Skinner reviewed Porter’s annual Language Arts Assessments schedule and the Grade 2/3 Reading Initiative which was prompted by very low CMT results for grade 3 in 2007.  Students were concentrated in the Below Basic and Goal areas.  There was the need to focus on improving students at all reading levels (differentiated instruction) and the need for comprehensive materials to address all needed skills at a wide range of abilities.   The new 2008 Houghton Mifflin Reading Program was implemented in early November, the DRA was administered in November and February, a benchmark test was administered in December to get a baseline assessment, and the report card terminology was correlated with the DRA levels/state criteria to establish a common, consistent criteria for measuring and expressing progress.  Mrs. Skinner reviewed the grade 2/3 reading initiative progress to date that shows substantial improvement in all areas of emerging, developing, and secure.

 

Mrs. Skinner reviewed the instructional focus for grades 5-8 and her role as L.A. Instructional Specialist.  In summarizing, the district will continue to move forward by:

·          defining next year’s approach for the grade 2/3 initiative

·          share and expand on newly approved CT State Department of Education Language Arts frameworks and supporting documents

·          create internal assessments for the new Grade Level Expectations in framework

·          analyze 2008 CMT results and define student needs for 2008-2009

·          expand reading instructional approaches for at risk students

·          continue to refine implementation of Houghton Mifflin and Sitton Word Study Programs

·          support DDDM Language Arts goals/efforts

·          continue to engage parent/guardian’s help in students’ reading success. 

 

Mrs. Skinner concluded by thanking the Porter staff for their flexibility this year.  Board members thanked Mrs. Skinner for her informative presentation.      

 

VII.     Financial Review

A.      Payment of Bills - Ms. Parrott provided answers for Board member’s questions.

 

VIII.   Reports/Discussion

A.   Board of Education Chairperson

1.   EASTCONN Annual Meeting May 27, 2008 @ 3:30 p.m. Hampton Central Office

2.   Ten Tips for Taming Controversial Meetings, The Board Report Volume 32 – Number 2  

B.   Board of Education Subcommittees

1.   Board of Education Meeting Dates Draft – May Through August 2008

2.   May 20, 2008 – Annual Town Budget Meeting @ 7:30 p.m. Porter Cafeteria – Dr. Saddlemire encouraged everyone to attend this meeting and to vote on May 29th.

C.   Superintendent’s Report

1.   First Student Transportation Contract

2.   Lebanon High School Tuition Contract & Meeting - Dr. Saddlemire reported Lebanon has suggested Columbia and Lebanon’s Superintendents, Board Chairs, Directors of Student Services and High School Principal meet on May 27th.   

3.      Psychologist/School Psychologist Definition – Dr. Saddlemire explained a School Psychologist identifies children with emotional and mental disturbances.  A psychologist makes medical diagnoses regarding emotional and mental disturbances.

4.      Staff Meeting – Dr. Saddlemire shared the Board of Education’s reluctance for the budget cuts and apologized to the grade 5 and 6 teams for not notifying them prior to the 5/15/08 staff meeting of the change from 4 class sections to 3 sections.

 

IX.      Action Items/Discussion

A.   2008/2009 Horace W. Porter School Calendar Approval – Second Reading   

 

L Green MOVED and W. Mulcahy SECONDED to approve the 2008/2009 Horace W. Porter School calendar as presented.

 

Board members discussed their support for DDDM and concerns regarding the number of interrupted weeks of instruction. 

 

MOTION CARRIES: 5-0-1

P. Belekewicz, C. Coley, L. Green, W. Mulcahy, N. Petrone VOTED FOR THE MOTION

L. Jurovaty ABSTAINED

 

 

 

IX.      Action Items/Discussion - continued

B.   2008/2009 Hot Lunch Price Increase Approval

W Mulcahy MOVED and L. Green SECONDED to approve the increase to the 2008/09 H. W. Porter School hot lunch prices of $3.00 for a student lunch and $3.50 for a staff lunch.

 

MOTION CARRIES: 5-1-0

C. Coley, L. Green, L. Jurovaty, W. Mulcahy, N. Petrone VOTED FOR THE MOTION

P. Belekewicz VOTED AGAINST THE MOTION

 

X.        Future Agenda Items

·          Strategic Plan – June 9 subcommittee meeting

·          Enrichment Specialist Update - June 2, 2008

 

XI.      Board of Education Member Comments

Mrs. Coley discussed the concept of an information sharing policy for meetings.  The Board of Education’s goal is not to keep information from FIPAC but to answer questions satisfactorily and be finished with that topic.  Mrs. Jurovaty said it is natural for FIPAC to ask questions of the Board and the Board should be open and answer all questions.  Mr. Petrone would like the Board to discuss a format for budget questions and would like questions to be directed from the FIPAC Chairperson.  The Board of Education is not hiding financial information.  Board members should be treated with respect and not accused of indiscretions.  Mrs. Coley asked the status of the Porter summer baseball camp.  Mrs. Belekewicz asked about kindergarten orientation.  (A parent meeting was held this evening for all incoming kindergarten parents, kindergarten orientation is June 13th from 9:00 a.m. to 10:15 a.m. and an open house is scheduled for August.)  Mrs. Belekewicz said she acts accordingly and being on the Board of Education is a huge responsibility.  Her Porter experience is based on the nine years her children have gone through the school system.           

 

XII.     Executive Session for the Purpose of Personnel Discussion

 

C. Coley MOVED and P. Belekewicz SECONDED to enter into executive session at 9:37 p.m.

 

MOTION CARRIES: 6-0

 

L. Jurovaty MOVED and W. Mulcahy SECONDED to adjourn executive session at 10:00 p.m.

 

MOTION CARRIES: 6-0

 

XIII.    Adjournment

C. Coley MOVED and L. Green SECONDED to adjourn the meeting at 10:01 p.m.

 

MOTION CARRIES: 6-0

 

 

 

 

Respectfully submitted,

 

 

 

 

Carol S. Coley, Vice Chairperson